Employers do not pay enough attention to the health risks associated with night work. Nor do they always comply with the rules on health and safety at work and working hours. The Netherlands Labour Authority investigated (Dutch) 285 employers in sectors where night work is common, including employers in manufacturing, transport, healthcare, the hospitality sector and distribution. For employers, economic reasons are the main factor in having work carried out at night. However, employees are the ones who bear the risks of this.
Of the 285 employers investigated, 193 were visited as part of the 'Arbo in Bedrijf' (Health & Safety at Work) survey and 92 were inspected for compliance with health and safety regulations and the Working Hours Act. Enforcement action was taken against 58 companies for breaches relating to health and safety, the Working Hours Act, or both. Furthermore, 20 per cent of the employers visited have staff working night shifts on a permanent basis, even though this is rarely permitted.
Night work is often carried out for economic reasons
The 'Arbo in Bedrijf' survey (Dutch) shows that, for 46 per cent of the employers surveyed, economic reasons play a key role, such as meeting production targets and serving customers. For 41 per cent, night work is necessary due to the nature of the job. For example, because work has to be carried out immediately, such as in the healthcare sector or the police force, or because systems cannot be shut down. Almost 9 out of 10 employers see no scope for further reducing night work. Consequently, the benefits of night work accrue to businesses and their customers, whilst employees bear the health risks, with part of the social costs being borne elsewhere.
Risks not adequately identified
Findings by the Netherlands Labour Authority also show that 54 per cent of the employers inspected had not identified night work as a separate risk. In 69 per cent of cases, the action plan lacks specific measures. Furthermore, employees do not always receive sufficient information. 63 per cent of the employers inspected say they inform employees about the risks of night work, but only half of the employees interviewed say they have received that information.
Working together to reduce night work
Employers can check whether work actually needs to be carried out at night. Where it is not necessary, night work should be reduced. If night work is necessary, employers must identify the risks and ensure that employees are properly protected. Reducing night work is not solely the responsibility of individual employers. Clients, employers' and employees' organisations and the government also have a role to play in this regard, for example by introducing simpler and stricter rules. After all, it has been known for years that night work is harmful to health. That knowledge should lead to a reduction in night work. Prevent where possible and provide good protection when it is unavoidable.
Night work is harmful to health
In the Netherlands, around 1.2 million people work at night, either occasionally or regularly. Night work disrupts the body's natural rhythm and increases the risk of sleep problems, cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes. Fatigue and reduced alertness also increase the risk of workplace accidents. But there is no reduction in the proportion of night workers, despite the Health Council of the Netherlands recommending back in 2017 that night work should be limited wherever possible.
